| 2023 NY-PENN BOYS BRACKET | ||
| SEMIFINAL | FINAL | |
| February 14, 2023 | February 18, 2023 | |
| 1 PA - Canaan Christian (14-1) | ||
| 2-0 No Score Reported | 1 PA - Canaan Christian (15-1) | |
| @ Higher Seed | ||
| 4 Twin Tiers Christian (8-10) | ||
| 54-46 | 1 PA - Canaan Christian (16-1) | |
| @ Higher Seed | NY-PENN Champion | |
| 3 Central Baptist (13-6) | ||
| 33-30 | 3 Central Baptist (14-6) | |
| @ Higher Seed | ||
| 2 Cortland Christian (12-2) | ||