| 2026 Staten Island Playoff Bracket | |||||
| PSAL/CHSAA | |||||
| PLAY-IN | ROUND 1 | QUARTERFINAL | SEMI FINAL | FINAL | |
| February 4, 2026 | February 5, 2026 | February 7, 2026 | February 9, 2026 | February 12, 2026 | |
| 1 Susan Wagner (16-8) | |||||
| 56-48 | 1 Susan Wagner (17-8) | ||||
| 9 Moore Catholic (3-15) | @ Petrides HS | ||||
| 51-49 | 8 Curtis (5-19) | ||||
| @ SI Tech | |||||
| 8 Curtis (4-19) | |||||
| 5:00 PM | |||||
| 5 SI Academy (17-3) | @ Petrides HS | ||||
| 61-49 | 5 SI Academy (18-3) | ||||
| 14 Port Richmond (5-15) | @ Port Richmond HS | ||||
| 80-53 | 12 Eagle Acad.-SI (8-16) | ||||
| @ Dreyfus School | 67-58 | 4 St. Joseph's BTS (13-8) | |||
| 12 Eagle Acad.-SI (7-16) | @ Petrides HS | ||||
| 4 St. Joseph's BTS (12-8) | |||||
| 7:00 PM | |||||
| @ Petrides HS | Staten Island Champion | ||||
| 3 Monsignor Farrell (12-8) | |||||
| 11 CSI/McCown (11-12) | |||||
| 64-44 | 3 Monsignor Farrell (13-8) | ||||
| 51-48 | 11 CSI/McCown (12-12) | @ Petrides HS | |||
| @ Highest Seed | |||||
| 14 Port Richmond (5-15) | |||||
| 60-45 | 6 New Dorp (17-7) | ||||
| @ Port Richmond HS | |||||
| 6 New Dorp (16-7) | |||||
| 7:00 PM | |||||
| 7 McKee/SI Tech (15-8) | @ Petrides HS | ||||
| 75-63 | 7 McKee/SI Tech (16-8) | ||||
| @ SI Tech | |||||
| 10 Tottenville (15-8) | |||||
| 77-51 | 2 St. Peter's (10-11) | ||||
| @ Petrides HS | |||||
| 2 St. Peter's (9-11) | |||||